Hi Elijah,
As a fellow Pixel owner and iFixit moderator, Pixel related questions that come up tend to catch my eye. One thing I have noticed is that the Pixels seem to have an initial failure rate for new screens that is higher than you would expect for genuine factory replacement parts (which is all that iFixit sells for Pixel phones).
Given that, and assuming you bought your screen from iFixit, then I'd suggest you take advantage of their lifetime warranty and contact them for a replacement. Best way I know of is to email them at support@ifixit.com, include your order number, and explain the situation.