メインコンテンツにスキップ
リペアコミュニティに参加 - アカウントの作成

1.8 GHz デュアルコア Intel Core i5(Turbo Boost使用時最大2.8 GHz)3MB L3キャッシュ

3 Beeps RAM repair gone wrong...?

We have a nice 2012 A1466 Air i7 model with 8 GB RAM that had the dreaded 3 beep RAM issue, Board # 820-3209. We have nicely re-balled all of the RAM chips but now the unit is totally dead, absolutly nothing going on when we connect a charger or try to power up normally. We have tested all the power rails and everything seems good with the readings. The issue must be with the RAM chips, either one 'or more' has failed or isn't seated all the way, we have since given them all a tiny wobble to try to fix this and probed the small components around the RAMs, technician says that they are giving good readings, We have done all the resets etc. How to test if a RAM chip is faulty? @oldturkey03 anything we may have missed here or is this beyond repair now?

この質問に回答する 同じ問題があります

この質問は役に立ちましたか?

スコア 0

2 件のコメント:

Why do you fix these 2012 MBAs? LOL love to see it anyway.

さんによる

@betatechlabsau I got them for free as defectives discarded from locals etc.... give them away afterwards or sell some on.... They are still good enough for what most people need from a laptop out here, just having an apple product pleases them LOL. Plus it is something to do and I learn things at the same time, so it is all a plus.

さんによる

コメントを追加

1 件の回答

If the board is completely dead after the RAM reball, the most likely cause is a bad solder joint, a misaligned RAM chip, or heat damage during the repair rather than the RAM itself. The best next step is to carefully inspect the soldering under a microscope or X-ray and reflow or reball the affected chip if anything looks questionable

このアンサーは役に立ちましたか?

スコア 0

7 件のコメント:

This is an obvious answer, but HOW do we check soldering that is under a chip that we re-balled? We will reflow them all again to see if it cured anything.....

さんによる

If you don't have access to X-ray, the practical options are pretty limited. I'd check for proper PP1V35/PP1V5 RAM power, verify all RAM related enable and reset signals, and inspect for any bridged or missing pads around the chip edges. If those look good, I'd reball one RAM chip at a time rather than reflowing them all together, since a single misaligned or open BGA joint is enough to leave the board completely dead.

さんによる

@mrdoom3412 OK I will go over it with what you mentioned and get back to you with my findings, it may need a few days. Thanks!

さんによる

@livfe - A friend of mine who does expensive electronics system repairs picked up from a closing dentist their Digital X-Ray system for $1500!!

For this exact reason as it's so tough to know if a pads solder ball shorted across two pads. He made an X-ray proof box to house the emitter and a way to hold the detector plate where he needed. His clients love the fact of getting the printout of the X-Ray of the repair.

さんによる

@danj Buying an X-Ray machine for $1500 to fix a $50 2012 MacBook air, sounds like a great idea if you have the type of business to support it, but as for me with maybe 2 old worthless MacBooks it doesn't make much economical sense to me.... Local hospital might help as they have X-Ray but they won't entertain the idea to X-Ray a MacBook and would likely laugh at the idea even. Never mind, I think this one is beyond my skills or patience to waste more time on. Needs an SSD anyway and they are hard to source and I am not buying a new M2 & converter as the sale price of the working unit would be less that the price of the SSD.

さんによる

2件以上のコメントを表示

コメントを追加

回答を追加する

livfe さん、ありがとうございました!
統計データ:

過去 24時間: 3

過去 7 日: 54

過去 30 日: 54

今までの合計 54