Cooling fan - exact part?

Question

MacBook Pro 17" Models A1151 A1212 A1229 and A1261

Non-Unibody, Core Duo & Core 2 Duo Processors

375回答すべてを表示

締切られた回答

HandyMac @handymac1988

評価: 289

7

1

投稿日: 2011年4月1日

オプション

Cooling fan - exact part?

The left fan in my MacBook Pro 17" 2.5GHz (Model A1261) has developed a noise (fluttering sound, bearings?). I got a replacement (sold as for this model), but it looks different from the original.

The original looks like the one on iFixIt's page for this fan, but the replacement I got looks like the one on the page for the Model A1151: same appearance (larger holes than the one in the computer now), design (fan has fewer vanes), manufacturer (Delta), even part # (KDB04505HA). Its connecting cord however is at the correct angle for the 1261 MBP (5 o'clock instead of 3 o'clock). Is this the only functional difference between the fans for the various MBP 17" models?

I'm concerned that having two fans of different designs in the computer might be a problem, since they work together. Does anyone know if this could be a problem?

製品

MacBook Pro 17" (Model A1151) Left Fan

$49.99

回答がありました！ 回答を表示同じ問題があります

この質問は役に立ちましたか？

はいいいえ

スコア 0

コメントを追加

1 件の回答

ベストアンサー

mayer @mayer

評価: 685.3千

MacHale Enterprises

3.4千

1.1千

2.6千

投稿日: 2011年4月1日

オプション

Send it back. That fan is not listed as a replacement for your machine.

このアンサーは役に立ちましたか？

はいいいえ

スコア 3

4 件のコメント:

Thanks for your response.

Actually, a Google search for the Apple Part # 922-8395 finds at least a half dozen online dealers offering fans that look like the one I got. So it seems the situation is a little confused. I'm awaiting assurance from iFixit that their fan is indeed as pictured; if so I'll probably buy that and send this one back.

HandyMac さんによる2011年4月2日

Just because parts LOOK alike does not mean they are Interchangeable. For instance, look at RAM.

mayer さんによる2011年4月2日

Well, iFixit assured me the fan would be as pictured, so I ordered it. When it arrived it was the Delta fan, the same as the one I already have. Meanwhile, the first vendor assured me the fan came from Apple and was the official replacement part. Apparently Apple is now using the same source for replacement fans for all the MBPs. So I'll use the first one, while the second one goes back to iFixit.

HandyMac さんによる2011年4月7日

I would contact iFixit for a confirmation on the part. If they confirm I would ask them to add the photo of the new one to the product list to avoid confusion in the future.

mayer さんによる2011年4月7日

コメントを追加

Thanks for your response.

Actually, a Google search for the Apple Part # 922-8395 finds at least a half dozen online dealers offering fans that look like the one I got. So it seems the situation is a little confused. I'm awaiting assurance from iFixit that their fan is indeed as pictured; if so I'll probably buy that and send this one back. — HandyMac
Just because parts LOOK alike does not mean they are Interchangeable. For instance, look at RAM. — mayer
Well, iFixit assured me the fan would be as pictured, so I ordered it. When it arrived it was the Delta fan, the same as the one I already have. Meanwhile, the first vendor assured me the fan came from Apple and was the official replacement part. Apparently Apple is now using the same source for replacement fans for all the MBPs. So I'll use the first one, while the second one goes back to iFixit. — HandyMac
I would contact iFixit for a confirmation on the part. If they confirm I would ask them to add the photo of the new one to the product list to avoid confusion in the future. — mayer