Replaced battery, conditioned, health is at 30%

Hello!

I recently installed a new battery into my macbook pro. After installing the battery I checked the health and saw that it was at 105%. I followed the conditioning instructions and after letting the battery fully drain and then charge to full, the health had dropped to 30%. This substantial drop is somewhat concerning to me as it somewhat defeats the purpose of even installing a new battery in the first place. Anyone know what's going on? Did i just get a bad battery?

Ryan

Health now has jumped to 105% but the charge percentage is down to 74%. Why is this data fluctuating so much?