Temperatures and Amps on the core & FBDIMM's

Question

Mac Pro (初代モデル)

初代Mac ProはIntel Xeonをベースにしたワークステーションコンピューターです。初代モデルには2006年から2008年のデバイスも含まれます。

317回答すべてを表示

Marco Battistella @tonmeister

評価: 23

2

投稿日: 2016年6月17日

オプション

Temperatures and Amps on the core & FBDIMM's

Dear All!

After upgrading my Mac Pro 3,1 with INTEL Quad Xeon 3,2GHz processors, 32Gb of RAM, USB 3 card and an SSD as startup disc, I installed iStat Menu to check whether or not my Mac Pro was doing OK.

So far, a few points I worry about; I hope somebody out there might have a suggestion for me:

- The "AMB IC FBDIMM in Riser A Slot 1 and 2" run at 128 degrees C all the time. Isn't that too much?

- Fans stay below 800rpm almost all the time. They would boost up in case the Mac gets too hot, right?

- CPU A-core draws in about 25Amps, while B draws in about 50Amps. That's way too much, right?

I'm talking about idle mode here - no heavy lifting - although I do realise that the CPU's rarely go below 13% load.

Every help is greatly appreciated.

All the best,

Marco

回答がありました！ 回答を表示同じ問題があります

この質問は役に立ちましたか？

はいいいえ

スコア 1

コメントを追加

3件の回答

ベストアンサー

mayer @mayer

評価: 685.3千

MacHale Enterprises

3.4千

1.1千

2.6千

投稿日: 2016年6月17日

オプション

A major upgrade like this requires you to resync the fans. This software is on your original system installation DVD.

このアンサーは役に立ちましたか？

はいいいえ

スコア 3

8 件のコメント:

Thanks for your help Mayer, I appreciate it. So basically an SMC reset is fine? I did that just now. I should have the original DVD somewhere - but I do not recall in which box... What do you think about the amps the CPU's are drawing? Too much, right?

Thanks,

M.

Marco Battistella さんによる2016年6月17日

Here's some info on power consumption on the different MacPros:

https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201796

mayer さんによる2016年6月17日

Hey Thanks for pointing me into the right directions! Much appreciated!

Marco Battistella さんによる2016年6月17日

Now that you have the fans working correctly, how your temps?

mayer さんによる2016年6月18日

Better! Especially the CPU cooled down, 37C for CPU A and 44C for CPU B. But the AMB IC on the FBDIMM's stays at 128C right from the start. So I guess there might be a wrong reading there. I will have, as Richard proposed, to check with an infrared thermometer.

Marco Battistella さんによる2016年6月19日

3件以上のコメントを表示

コメントを追加

Thanks for your help Mayer, I appreciate it. So basically an SMC reset is fine? I did that just now. I should have the original DVD somewhere - but I do not recall in which box... What do you think about the amps the CPU's are drawing? Too much, right?

Thanks,

M. — Marco Battistella
Here's some info on power consumption on the different MacPros:

https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201796 — mayer
Hey Thanks for pointing me into the right directions! Much appreciated! — Marco Battistella
Now that you have the fans working correctly, how your temps? — mayer
Better! Especially the CPU cooled down, 37C for CPU A and 44C for CPU B. But the AMB IC on the FBDIMM's stays at 128C right from the start. So I guess there might be a wrong reading there. I will have, as Richard proposed, to check with an infrared thermometer. — Marco Battistella

Richard Reichle @richr67 評価: 97 4 1 1 · Answer 1 · 2016-06-17T11:04:11-07:00

Richard Reichle @richr67

評価: 97

4

1

投稿日: 2016年6月17日

オプション

Marco

128 C or F? If its C that is very hot!

Fully Buffered DIMM (FB-DIMMs) can run hot and often require forced air cooling so you may have to add a fan and even look into heat sinks for the RAM if they don't already have them.

As far as your CPU's I have read some things online that say that amount of current is possible it seems high to me but perhaps someone else could weigh in on that aspect of it??

Hope I helped a little

このアンサーは役に立ちましたか？

はいいいえ

スコア 0

3 件のコメント:

Celsius! But iStat Menu shows 128C right from the boot up. This temperature never changes. Could it be that the sensors are not working? I don't think the FBDIMMS get that hot right from the start?

I will look into that - how to fit one more cooler between the risers.

Regarding the CPU's, Mayer's answer helped a lot. I reset PRAM and SMC and that did the trick - resynced fans AND took the load of the CPU's which were constantly at over 50% - even in idle mode. now, they barely go above 20% under heavy load. In idle, they stay below 2%.

Marco Battistella さんによる2016年6月17日

I suppose it's possible your readings are not correct especially since they are reading that hot from first boot and it never changes and I am assuming the system is running ok nothing weird going on?

Any chance you have infrared thermometer so you could take a reading right of the dimms? Forgive me for being a salesmen but ifixit has one for $20 I think, but after doing the reset if the system is stable I would think you are ok.

Richard Reichle さんによる2016年6月18日

Thanks for the help. I do have an infrared thermometer, I just don't know in which box it's in (recently moved). Will do so as soon as I find it. The system is running very stable - no worries there. So I just think the reading is off. I did purchase FBDIMM's with slim heatsinks; I am worried that those (32GB) might be the problem - but still, 128C constant temperature seems odd to me.

Marco Battistella さんによる2016年6月19日

コメントを追加

quangtrungdesigner @quangtrung64298 評価: 49 2 2 · Answer 2 · 2017-07-04T19:26:36-07:00

quangtrungdesigner @quangtrung64298

評価: 49

2

投稿日: 2017年7月4日

オプション

The "AMB IC FB-DIMM in Riser A Slot 1 and 2" run at 128 degrees C, because of the RAM that you installed on your system. It's reading error from iStat Menus.

Try different manufacture of RAM to find a better match for your system!

このアンサーは役に立ちましたか？

はいいいえ

スコア 0

コメントを追加

Mac Pro (初代モデル)

Temperatures and Amps on the core & FBDIMM's

3件の回答

回答を追加する